Survey: ~50% of Gen Z say they get better career advice from ChatGPT than their manager

A young Black woman leads her team in a project meeting

By

INTOO Staff Writer

Categories

INTOO, the career development and outplacement flagship for Gi Group Holding, a global leader in HR and talent solutions, today announced the publication of its Unlocking Organizational Success by Supporting Employee Growth and Development report: a summary of findings from a new survey that explores how support for career advancement—and the lack thereof—is impacting today’s workforce.

In partnership with research firm Workplace Intelligence, INTOO surveyed 800 HR leaders and 800 full-time employees. The report describes how many workers struggle to progress in their careers due to a lack of support from their employers. However, Gen Z—the fastest-growing employee demographic—feels particularly lost, even though these team members stand to benefit the most from learning & career development programs and opportunities. 

Key findings include:

Many employees feel unsupported in their career development—and organizations might struggle to retain talent as a result:

  • 63% say their employer cares more about their productivity than their career development
  • 54% feel completely on their own at their organization when it comes to their career development
  • 25% of employees—and an alarming 44% of Gen Z—say they’ll likely quit within the next 6 months because their company doesn’t support their career development.

Managers play a critical role in helping people advance their careers, but employees don’t feel they can rely on them:

  • 46% of employees say their manager doesn’t know how to help them with their career development.
  • Nearly half (47%) of Gen Z employees say they get better career advice from Artificial Intelligence, including ChatGPT, than they get from their manager.
  • Workers who feel at least “somewhat” supported by their manager were nearly 7X more likely to say they made a lot of career progress last year compared to those who say they get little or no support from their manager.

Learning & development programs offer important benefits to workers and companies alike, but most aren’t hitting the mark:

  • Just 22% of employees and 41% of HR leaders say their company’s L&D opportunities and benefits are “excellent.”
  • At least 8 out of 10 employees say that having access to best-in-class L&D opportunities would increase their engagement, job satisfaction, motivation at work, and likelihood of staying at their company. Nearly all Gen Z employees—97% or more—say these outcomes would increase for them.

The solution? Empower your managers and enhance your company’s learning & development programs.

For companies, a better path forward will require a two-fold approach that involves: (1) providing more support and training for managers and (2) offering better L&D benefits and opportunities.

“Only half of the HR leaders we surveyed say managers at their company receive training when hired on how to provide career development guidance for their team members,” said Dan Schawbel, Managing Partner, Workplace Intelligence. “What’s more, around a third of employees say they talk with their manager about their career just once a year or never.”

“The fact is, managers are often stretched too thin to focus on career development for their team members, and they don’t know how to provide good career advice,” Schawbel added. “Leaders need to prioritize addressing these issues if they want to retain their talent and bolster their efforts around internal mobility.”

The study also revealed that most companies could be doing more to provide their team members with a best-in-class learning & development experience. “In our research, we found that the majority of workers expect their organization to offer courses, classes, opportunities to support projects in other areas of the business, tuition reimbursement, and mentorship or career coaching,” said Mira Greenland, CRO, INTOO. “However, a relatively low number of leaders report that their companies offer these benefits.”

“Even more noteworthy is that 74% of employees say L&D opportunities and benefits are just as valuable or more valuable than a promotion or title change. This is good news for employers since these programs often cost far less than salary increases.”

To learn more about the research, read the full report: Unlocking Organizational Success by Supporting Employee Growth and Development.

Methodology

Research findings are based on a survey conducted by INTOO and Workplace Intelligence between November 19 – December 2, 2023. In total, 1,600 full-time, U.S-based employees completed the survey, including 800 HR leaders and 800 employees. Respondents were invited to take part in the survey via email and were provided with a small monetary incentive for doing so. All respondents had passed a double opt-in process and completed an average of 300 profiling data points prior to taking part in the survey.

About INTOO

With offices in the US, UK, Ireland, Italy, Brazil, and Argentina, INTOO is the career development and outplacement flagship for Gi Group Holding, a global leader in HR and talent solutions, and is also a founding member of Career Star Group’s global network of outplacement providers. We bring 20+ years of experience in delivering high-touch, people-focused programs to more than 20,000 companies around the world.

About Workplace Intelligence

Workplace Intelligence is an award-winning thought leadership and research agency focused on the world of work. We help companies, and their executives, tell their workplace story in a meaningful, relevant, and impactful way using primary data, insights, and interviews. For more information go to our website and subscribe to our Insider newsletter.

INTOO Staff Writer

INTOO staff writers come from diverse backgrounds and have extensive experience writing about topics that matter to the HR and business communities, including outplacement, layoffs, career development, internal mobility, candidate experience, succession planning, talent acquisition, and more.

Learn how to effectively build and transition your workforce.

Latest Posts

Transferable Skills to Thrive in Today’s Evolving Workforce
Transferable Skills to Thrive in Today’s Evolving Workforce

The workplace is constantly shifting, and the need to adapt has never been greater.  A career journey can span multiple positions within a single organization or with several employers, across industries.  Each time an individual makes a career transition, their...

What Are OKRs? A Comprehensive Guide
What Are OKRs? A Comprehensive Guide

Objectives and key results, or OKRs for short, are a goal-setting framework that helps organizations align their strategic vision with measurable outcomes. They consist of clearly defined objectives that outline what you want to achieve, paired with key results that...

How to Make Employees Feel Valued at Work
How to Make Employees Feel Valued at Work

Behind every successful organization are individuals who contribute their passion and purpose to get results. While each team member has their personal motivations that drive them, when they feel recognized for their contributions and that their voices are heard, they...

Workplace Mentoring: A Guide to Empower Your Team
Workplace Mentoring: A Guide to Empower Your Team

Workplace mentoring is a professional relationship in which a less experienced employee (the mentee) receives guidance, support, and advice from a more experienced or knowledgeable colleague (the mentor). This relationship goes beyond teaching the skills specific to a...

What Is a Crisis Management Plan (CMP) and Why Is It Important? 
What Is a Crisis Management Plan (CMP) and Why Is It Important? 

A variety of unexpected crises can strike a business without warning.  The company website crashes during a major product launch. A storm floods the office, leaving the team without a workspace. A leader must take an extended period away from work or leave altogether....

What Is Coffee Badging? 
What Is Coffee Badging? 

Coffee badging is a workplace trend in which employees briefly appear at the office, often just long enough to grab a coffee and interact with colleagues before leaving the premises to tackle things remotely. The term "coffee badging" refers to the act of employees...

Employee Strengths and How to Identify Them
Employee Strengths and How to Identify Them

A business is only as strong as its people. Employee’s talents, skills, and unique capabilities form the foundation of a company’s success. But identifying and leveraging employee strengths doesn’t only enhance workplace performance. It also boosts morale, engagement,...

What Are Feedback Models and When Should They Be Used?
What Are Feedback Models and When Should They Be Used?

Feedback is an essential tool for growth and success in the workplace. Whether addressing areas for improvement, celebrating achievements, or fostering collaboration, effective feedback helps individuals and teams thrive. How feedback is delivered is just as important...

How to Handle Difficult Conversations at Work
How to Handle Difficult Conversations at Work

Inevitably, difficult conversations will arise in any workplace. As a manager or leader, you likely bear the responsibility of navigating these challenging interactions. Whether you're addressing performance issues, providing critical feedback to employees, mediating...

Subscribe to our newsletter!

Learn about career solutions and trends that matter to the HR community.