How to Provide Feedback to an Employee

A young Black woman leads her team in a project meeting

By

INTOO Staff Writer

Categories

HR

Knowing how to offer feedback to your professionals is a valuable skill that can lead to enhanced workplace performance. However, it may be hard for you as a leader to find the right way to phrase your thoughts without sounding overly critical. Here, we’ll show you how to communicate with your employees in a constructive manner so they get the most out of feedback—whether offered during review periods or at any other time it’s needed.

How to Give Feedback to an Employee

1. Be timely

Feedback should be provided in a timely manner, preferably when an issue arises, so that the employee has the opportunity to make improvements as quickly as possible, or—in the case of positive feedback—maintain the practices that are working well. If you wait until review periods to offer constructive criticism, the employee may wonder why the issue wasn’t raised earlier, and the details of the event that caused concern may become fuzzy. Offering feedback soon after the event creates the greatest opportunity for the clearest insight and remediation.

2. Be professional

Each feedback session should be taken seriously by both manager and employee. Set the tone by speaking in a calm, collected manner and keeping the conversation relevant to your critiques. Showing any signs of irritation or anger towards underperforming employees could negatively impact their workplace satisfaction and trust in you as a supervisor, so be sure to avoid verbally lashing out during the meeting.

3. Provide the facts

Supporting your statements with factual information can help your employees better understand how their actions have impacted the company. Not incorporating opinions into your feedback will also ensure your critiques are free from bias. Facts add an element of fairness to the feedback that can’t be dismissed by the employee being reviewed, so consider providing some specific examples of where they have or haven’t met expectations.

4. Give context

If your feedback is too vague, the employee may misinterpret your comments and take the wrong lessons away from your meeting. It’s crucial to avoid generalized complaints or compliments when giving critiques. Simply saying someone is doing well or badly at a task doesn’t give them the appropriate context for what specific actions elicited that feedback.

A female employees responds to feedback from her male manager in a meeting.5. Allow the employee to respond

Managers should take the time to pay attention to their direct reports when offering feedback. There may be situations where an employee can explain why they’ve been underperforming at work. Communicate with your professionals to see if you can assist them with their problems. Taking the time to listen to the employee will also let them feel respected in the workplace.

Balance the negatives with positives

An overwhelmingly negative meeting can significantly impact an employee’s morale. You can still incorporate positivity into the review without sugarcoating the truth, such as highlighting which aspects of the position they excel at. Try coming up with constructive plans during the meeting for how employees can approach their work to end the session on a hopeful note.

Employee Feedback Examples

Below are some examples of how you can provide both positive and negative feedback to employees. 

Positive feedback example 1

“You did a great job handling that customer’s complaint. Staying respectful of the client while calmly discussing the problem stopped the issue from escalating and maintained their brand loyalty. You really upheld our core values in that situation.”

Positive feedback example 2

“Great work on the report you submitted yesterday. I appreciate that you followed our formatting guidelines and completed the assignment before the deadline. The thorough analysis you provided helped support your claims. Thank you for setting a good example for the team.”

Positive feedback example 3

“The presentation you gave at last week’s team meeting was excellent. Your confidence throughout the discussion reinforced your authority on the subject and held everyone’s attention. I also thought the icebreaker activity you included at the start perfectly captured our workplace culture.”

A male manager offers constructive feedback to his female employeeNegative feedback example 1

“It appears you did not meet your sales quota according to your performance metrics from the last quarter. Failing to meet or surpass your quota will impact the organization’s profitability, so we should discuss some strategies you can use to increase your sales for this quarter.”

Negative feedback example 2

“There have been multiple negative reviews by customers mentioning your behavior toward them over the phone. As a representative of our brand, you must avoid creating poor relationships with our clientele. Can you tell me more about what happened in these instances?”

Negative feedback example 3

“An email newsletter was sent out to a large mailing list that contained incorrect information. This was human error, and more time could have been taken to thoroughly check the email before sending it. What processes can we put in place to avoid this in the future?”

Employers should always look out for the best interests of their professionals. Sometimes, the greatest assistance you can give an employee is offering honest, tactfully phrased feedback that helps them improve their skills. Following these guidelines will help you approach your feedback discussions with confidence.Knowing how to offer feedback to your professionals is a valuable skill that can lead to enhanced workplace performance. However, it may be hard for you as a leader to find the right way to phrase your thoughts without sounding overly critical. Here, we’ll show you how to communicate with your employees in a constructive manner so they get the most out of feedback—whether offered during review periods or at any other time it’s needed.

How to Give Feedback to an Employee

Be timely

Feedback should be provided in a timely manner, preferably when an issue arises, so that the employee has the opportunity to make improvements as quickly as possible, or—in the case of positive feedback—maintain the practices that are working well. If you wait until review periods to offer constructive criticism, the employee may wonder why the issue wasn’t raised earlier, and the details of the event that caused concern may become fuzzy. Offering feedback soon after the event creates the greatest opportunity for the clearest insight and remediation.

Be professional

Each feedback session should be taken seriously by both manager and employee. Set the tone by speaking in a calm, collected manner and keeping the conversation relevant to your critiques. Showing any signs of irritation or anger towards underperforming employees could negatively impact their workplace satisfaction and trust in you as a supervisor, so be sure to avoid verbally lashing out during the meeting.

Provide the facts

Supporting your statements with factual information can help your employees better understand how their actions have impacted the company. Not incorporating opinions into your feedback will also ensure your critiques are free from bias. Facts add an element of fairness to the feedback that can’t be dismissed by the employee being reviewed, so consider providing some specific examples of where they have or haven’t met expectations.

Give context

If your feedback is too vague, the employee may misinterpret your comments and take the wrong lessons away from your meeting. It’s crucial to avoid generalized complaints or compliments when giving critiques. Simply saying someone is doing well or badly at a task doesn’t give them the appropriate context for what specific actions elicited that feedback.

A female employees responds to feedback from her male manager in a meeting.Allow the employee to respond

Managers should take the time to pay attention to their direct reports when offering feedback. There may be situations where an employee can explain why they’ve been underperforming at work. Communicate with your professionals to see if you can assist them with their problems. Taking the time to listen to the employee will also let them feel respected in the workplace.

Balance the negatives with positives

An overwhelmingly negative meeting can significantly impact an employee’s morale. You can still incorporate positivity into the review without sugarcoating the truth, such as highlighting which aspects of the position they excel at. Try coming up with constructive plans during the meeting for how employees can approach their work to end the session on a hopeful note.

Employee Feedback Examples

Below are some examples of how you can provide both positive and negative feedback to employees. 

Positive feedback example 1

“You did a great job handling that customer’s complaint. Staying respectful of the client while calmly discussing the problem stopped the issue from escalating and maintained their brand loyalty. You really upheld our core values in that situation.”

Positive feedback example 2

“Great work on the report you submitted yesterday. I appreciate that you followed our formatting guidelines and completed the assignment before the deadline. The thorough analysis you provided helped support your claims. Thank you for setting a good example for the team.”

Positive feedback example 3

“The presentation you gave at last week’s team meeting was excellent. Your confidence throughout the discussion reinforced your authority on the subject and held everyone’s attention. I also thought the icebreaker activity you included at the start perfectly captured our workplace culture.”

A male manager offers constructive feedback to his female employeeNegative feedback example 1

“It appears you did not meet your sales quota according to your performance metrics from the last quarter. Failing to meet or surpass your quota will impact the organization’s profitability, so we should discuss some strategies you can use to increase your sales for this quarter.”

Negative feedback example 2

“There have been multiple negative reviews by customers mentioning your behavior toward them over the phone. As a representative of our brand, you must avoid creating poor relationships with our clientele. Can you tell me more about what happened in these instances?”

Negative feedback example 3

“An email newsletter was sent out to a large mailing list that contained incorrect information. This was human error, and more time could have been taken to thoroughly check the email before sending it. What processes can we put in place to avoid this in the future?”

Employers should always look out for the best interests of their professionals. Sometimes, the greatest assistance you can give an employee is offering honest, tactfully phrased feedback that helps them improve their skills. Following these guidelines will help you approach your feedback discussions with confidence. INTOO’s coaches help employees in every stage of their career develop strategies to meet their goals, while employers reap the benefits of increased engagement, productivity, and retention. Learn more about how our career development programs can benefit your company.

INTOO Staff Writer

INTOO staff writers come from diverse backgrounds and have extensive experience writing about topics that matter to the HR and business communities, including outplacement, layoffs, career development, internal mobility, candidate experience, succession planning, talent acquisition, and more.

Learn how to effectively build and transition your workforce.

Latest Posts

12 Effective Team Brainstorming Techniques
12 Effective Team Brainstorming Techniques

Need help to ignite innovation within your team? Traditional brainstorming and feedback sessions can sometimes fall flat, leading to repetitive ideas and a lack of engagement. This article explores 12 creative and effective team brainstorming techniques to get your...

How to Hire Employees
How to Hire Employees

The competition for skilled workers remains fierce. Businesses of all sizes are grappling with talent shortages, demanding a strategic shift in attracting, assessing, and retaining top employees. Navigating the contemporary job market requires a strategic and...

What Are High-Potential Employees?
What Are High-Potential Employees?

High-potential employees (HIPOs) are your company's future leaders. They're the individuals who excel in their current roles but have the drive and ability to take on much more. They have a strong desire and insatiable taste for growth. Imagine employees consistently...

Company Acquisitions and Mergers: Definition, Differences, and Examples
Company Acquisitions and Mergers: Definition, Differences, and Examples

Company acquisitions and mergers: is a merger the same thing as an acquisition? Surprisingly, although the two terms are frequently paired, each process means something slightly different.  What Is a Merger vs. Acquisition in Business? A merger requires two companies...

What Is a Leadership Development Strategy?
What Is a Leadership Development Strategy?

A leadership development strategy outlines a systematic approach to nurturing and enhancing the skills, qualities, and behaviors essential for effective leadership within an organization. It involves identifying current and future leaders, assessing their strengths...

What Are Professional Development Goals? 12 Real-World Examples
What Are Professional Development Goals? 12 Real-World Examples

Personal growth is important for all employees, regardless of industry or position. However, no job can teach people all the skills needed to become well-rounded professionals. Knowing how to actively seek out opportunities to help you grow as a leader is a valuable...

11 Ways to Improve Employee Morale
11 Ways to Improve Employee Morale

The way your professionals feel about their jobs can affect their productivity and quality of work. Businesses may find themselves struggling to maintain high motivation among their employees and it can be challenging to determine how to boost employees’ morale. We've...

Subscribe to our newsletter!

Learn about career solutions and trends that matter to the HR community.